Live Sets and Mixes

[Tunny1711]

Hi mates,

Question, may we talk about scene livesets releases?

[Hunter]

Hi mates,

Question, may we talk about scene livesets releases?

We can always talk, anytime and about anything

[Tunny1711]

I mean, if will be good to create a separate section for livesets requests.
For example, i will be very happy to have a few very old great livesets, but don´t know at this time, if I can create a request directly in AUDIO requests. Due to fact, that I have 3 warnings

Let´s have a look:

Code: Select all

benefiz_rave-dj_lee_live_(ssl)-sat-08-02-2005-1real
divini_and_warning_-_live_at_beachclub_vroeger_(bloemendaal)-cable-08-11-2007-talion
dj_lee_and_ziggyx_-_live_at_ziegelei-(future_trance_party)-09-10-2006-fmc
dj_lee-live_at_atrium_kiel_(ssl)-sat-14-05-2006-1king
dj_lee-live_at_megadrome_(ssl)-sat-19-11-2005-1king
dj_lee-united_night_live_(ssl)-sat-19-10-2005-1king
megara_vs._dj_lee-live_at_go_park_herford-sat-28-05-2005-1real
nature_one_2012_-_benjamin_reichert_live-sat-08-04-2012-talion
pulsedriver-live_at_delta_musikpark-read_nfo-sat-24-05-2003-1real
tiesto_in_concert-live_at_gelredome_arnhem_(holland)-3fm-sat-05-11-2003-twclive

[T87.Rave]

unfortunately there is no section for livestes and mixes,
but you can post REQs in *AUDIO REQUESTS* section for live sets.

FOUND:
benefiz_rave-dj_lee_live_(ssl)-sat-08-02-2005-1real
dj_lee-live_at_atrium_kiel_(ssl)-sat-14-05-2006-1king
dj_lee-live_at_megadrome_(ssl)-sat-19-11-2005-1king
dj_lee-united_night_live_(ssl)-sat-19-10-2005-1king
dj_lee_and_ziggyx_-_live_at_ziegelei-(future_trance_party)-09-10-2006-fmc
megara_vs._dj_lee-live_at_go_park_herford-sat-28-05-2005-1real
pulsedriver-live_at_delta_musikpark-read_nfo-sat-24-05-2003-1real
tiesto_in_concert-live_at_gelredome_arnhem_(holland)-3fm-sat-05-11-2003-twclive

NOT FOUND:
divini_and_warning_-_live_at_beachclub_vroeger_(bloemendaal)-cable-08-11-2007-talion
nature_one_2012_-_benjamin_reichert_live-sat-08-04-2012-talion

[Hunter]

nature_one_2012_-_benjamin_reichert_live-sat-08-04-2012-talion

This one I have if something

[T87.Rave]

if will be good to create a separate section for livesets requests.

i agree, because i think we need sections like this for all category just one time ....

Forum
General Discussion
SFV/NFO/M3U Requests

Forum - MP3
*MP3 - REQUESTS*
*MP3 - FiLLED*
*MP3 - Archived Requests*

Forum - FLAC
*FLAC - REQUESTS*
*FLAC - FiLLED*
*FLAC - Archived*

Forum - LIVESETS and DJ Mixes
*LIVESETS and Mixes - REQUESTS*
*LIVESETS and Mixes - FiLLED*
*LIVESETS and Mixes - Archived*

Forum - MUSIC VIDEO
*MVIDS - REQUESTS*
*MVIDS - FiLLED*
*MVIDS - Archived*

In my opinion, we either create separate REQ/FILL sections for MP3, FLAC, MVIDS and possibly LIVESETS and ABOOKS

hunter opinion was right.

[Hunter]

General Discussion

Forum - MP3
*MP3 - REQUESTS*
*MP3 - FiLLED*
*MP3 - Archived*

Forum - FLAC
*FLAC - REQUESTS*
*FLAC - FiLLED*
*FLAC - Archived*

Forum - LIVESETS and DJ Mixes
*LIVESETS and Mixes - REQUESTS*
*LIVESETS and Mixes - FiLLED*
*LIVESETS and Mixes - Archived*

Forum - MUSIC VIDEO
*MVIDS - REQUESTS*
*MVIDS - FiLLED*
*MVIDS - Archived*

Forum - OTHER REQs
*SFV/NFO/M3U REQUESTS*
*Release Names*
*ID Tracks*
*OTHER REQs FiLLED*

Yeah, it would be perfect... Just one more thing, you know what it is, and I have no more comments

But if we manage to convince @euphoricvocals to make such a split, it would be best to set a limit of max 5 REQs open at once for each section and a MANDATORY limit of max 5 REQs / 24h. Then we'll give users chance to have more active REQs at once, but also there will be no sudden large increase in new topics at a day. And finally there will be order all over the forum and it will be easier to find everything. In my opinion - optimal solution for this forum


PS. But I don't envy mods who will have to move all filled FLAC REQs to the new section

[DaScientific]

To be hoest i dont really get, why we need a seperate section for each category. When i get the OP right (which im unsure of), he wants another section für Livesets, because he already got over the request limit in the normal section. Even tho, ABOOK and LIVESETS are seperated on most sites, as far as i know, those releases also get raced/traded to MP3 and FLAC sections on sites that dont seperate this.
I'm some kind of scared that we will have a section for each genre of music next.

As a liveset "connoisseur" (i would tell myself and @radiofan), I have had no problems in the past with the existing sections.

In case i got OP right, we also could lift the request limit to whatever he wants to request but cant, because he already reached that limit. I personally would prefer this over another section.

Because I'm taking wild (and probably controversial) guesses (sorry about that, I dont wanna insult anyone), I would like to know, why we need another section. Is this only about aesthetics?

[T87.Rave]

well then we can merge 3 audio section together,

*MP3 - REQUESTS* + *FLAC - REQUESTS* + *LIVESETS and Mixes - REQUESTS*

but we still need a section for MVID
Forum - MUSIC VIDEO
*MVIDS - REQUESTS*
*MVIDS - FiLLED*
*MVIDS - Archived*

if we don't then there is big mix up and personally i think its not good or better,
and also it doesn't make any sense that all FiLLED posts goes together into one section.

there are two benefits of each section if we make,
#1 as hunter say it will be easier to find everything.
#2 we can know the total count of post from each sections.

example: if someone need a audio in FLAC format so they will straight go to the section with no Problem.

but everything's goes into together, i don't think so it's a good idea.

[Tunny1711]

Hi mates,

No no, It's not about aesthetic, nor about making more requests..
Simply said, the AUDIO section is excellent, every user can find or ask for their specific thing that they know is original.
Original in the sense that it is a full-fledged scene release, at best immediately in FLAC format.
Livesets are not original, they are rips from radios, or websites, etc ..yes, they are original scene releases, but they are not the stuff you find on discogs.com..
My opinion.